Who Pays? Public School Reimbursement Requirements After Newport & Cumberland v. DCYF

By Sean Clough & Jacob Evans

On February 3, 2026, the Rhode Island Supreme Court ruled that public schools are no longer required to pay the per-pupil special education rate nor the general education costs for students placed by DCYF in a residential facility.

In 2018, two children in the custody of the Department of Children, Youth, and Families (“DCYF”) were placed in a residential facility with an educational program. The Family Court designated Newport and Cumberland as the school departments responsible for educating the children. While at these facilities neither child received special education services. Nevertheless, DCYF charged the two school districts for their per-pupil special education rate.

DCYF filed a petition at Rhode Island Department of Education (“RIDE”) seeking payment from the two districts. The matter made its way to the Rhode Island Supreme Court.

The RI Supreme Court addressed two issues. First, whether the school districts are required to pay the per-pupil special education rate despite the students not receiving special education services. Second, whether state law requires school districts to reimburse DCYF at the per-pupil general education rate for students placed in a residential facility receiving general education services.

The Court held that the school districts are not required to pay the per-pupil special education rate, but the actual cost of special education services for those students in a residential facility. As for the second issue, the court held that there was no statutory requirement to pay for the general education of students in a residential facility.

What does this mean for school districts?

  • Continue to carefully evaluate when students reside in their district and contest their financial responsibility if the student is not considered a resident of the school district under Rhode Island law.
  • If responsible, however, districts are only responsible for the actual cost to educate a special education student. Districts should inquire about the accuracy of those costs before reimbursing any invoices to DCYF.
  • Finally, districts may have ongoing reimbursement cases with DCYF that should be reviewed to confirm that the district is paying the appropriate rate.

If you have any questions regarding this recent decision, please follow up with your legal counsel or an education attorney at BSK.